Arm Community
Arm Community
  • Site
  • User
  • Site
  • Search
  • User
  • Groups
    • Research Collaboration and Enablement
    • DesignStart
    • Education Hub
    • Innovation
    • Open Source Software and Platforms
  • Forums
    • AI and ML forum
    • Architectures and Processors forum
    • Arm Development Platforms forum
    • Arm Development Studio forum
    • Arm Virtual Hardware forum
    • Automotive forum
    • Compilers and Libraries forum
    • Graphics, Gaming, and VR forum
    • High Performance Computing (HPC) forum
    • Infrastructure Solutions forum
    • Internet of Things (IoT) forum
    • Keil forum
    • Morello Forum
    • Operating Systems forum
    • SoC Design and Simulation forum
    • 中文社区论区
  • Blogs
    • AI and ML blog
    • Announcements
    • Architectures and Processors blog
    • Automotive blog
    • Graphics, Gaming, and VR blog
    • High Performance Computing (HPC) blog
    • Infrastructure Solutions blog
    • Innovation blog
    • Internet of Things (IoT) blog
    • Operating Systems blog
    • Research Articles
    • SoC Design and Simulation blog
    • Smart Homes
    • Tools, Software and IDEs blog
    • Works on Arm blog
    • 中文社区博客
  • Support
    • Arm Support Services
    • Documentation
    • Downloads
    • Training
    • Arm Approved program
    • Arm Design Reviews
  • Community Help
  • More
  • Cancel
Arm Community blogs
Arm Community blogs
Announcements Inclusion and the red pepper problem
  • Blogs
  • Mentions
  • Sub-Groups
  • Tags
  • Jump...
  • Cancel
More blogs in Arm Community blogs
  • AI and ML blog

  • Announcements

  • Architectures and Processors blog

  • Automotive blog

  • Embedded blog

  • Graphics, Gaming, and VR blog

  • High Performance Computing (HPC) blog

  • Infrastructure Solutions blog

  • Internet of Things (IoT) blog

  • Operating Systems blog

  • SoC Design and Simulation blog

  • Tools, Software and IDEs blog

Tags
  • DE&I
  • Global Women @ Arm
Actions
  • RSS
  • More
  • Cancel
Related blog posts
Related forum threads

Inclusion and the red pepper problem

Simon Kinsey
Simon Kinsey
March 30, 2022
4 minute read time.

I was reading a book recently about Diversity and Inclusion (Roscoe, 2019). There was a quote by Verna Myers (2012), that Diversity is being invited to the party, and inclusion is being asked to dance. Is this right? It sounds nice - like having a room full of people happily dancing to loud music, having fun together. It is a social, extrovert experience of fun that is assumed to be universal. I would not want to deprive gregarious people of a fun-filled party, but you would not find me attending it. It is not how I do fun.

If we want an organization to be inclusive, we need to think about how it works for everyone. It is not created by inviting everyone to a dance and then requiring them to dance. It appears to be inclusive but it does not lead to any structural change. If anything, it simply reinforces the power of party-organizers discussed by Daniel Juday in his article, “Inclusion Is Not Being Asked to Dance”, 2017.

The Chilli Pepper Problem

Inclusion reminds me of the Chilli Pepper Problem, or the Tale of Two Cities, a simple model discussed in the book, Complex Adaptive Systems (Miller, Page 2007). It goes like this:

Imagine a county in which people are genetically pre-disposed to like either green chillis or red chillis, but not both. The government of this country wants its citizens to be as happy as possible and to socialize to swap ideas and innovations. The government therefore organizes an annual picnic and lets each town discuss and vote democratically on the type of chilli to provide at the picnic.

This country has only two towns. They either can decide to have a green chilli picnic, or a red chilli picnic depending on the outcome of elections.

Now the towns both have just 3 people in them, 2 green chilli eaters, and 1 red chilli eater. They meet, chat and vote fairly, and both towns choose to have a green chilli party in accordance with the wishes of the majority.

Diagram: Chilli Pepper Picnic Votes

Chilli Pepper Picnic Votes

The government was pleased at the success of these events and wanted to conduct a Chilli Pulse Survey to measure the extent of its success. They thought they would have created a 90% happiness rating. They were shocked at the final score though: just 66% of the population were happy. They told the towns that they had to meet fairly before the vote to discuss in full the chilli requirements and argue out their differences. 

The following year, the annual picnic meetings in both towns became heated and divisive. Green chilli eaters could not understand why the lone red chilli eater in their community hated green chillies so much. Red chilli eaters felt misunderstood and alienated. The vote happened: each town still wanted green chillies served, which was the democratic, majority choice. Nobody could disagree with the result. The picnics happened, everyone seemed happy, and the Chilli Pulse Survey was conducted again. 

This time, the score was 100%. Everyone who attended the event enjoyed it and felt happy. The government was delighted. However, 33% of the population did not attend the party, and they all seemed to be the red chilli eaters. This was not the government intention. It now had happy citizens and alienated citizens. It decided to set up a Red Chilli Eater Support Group, and also a Green Chilli Eater Support Group for reasons of equality. 

During the next year, there was a lot of discussion and problem solving in the Red Chilli Group. A steering committee was created, a JIRA board set up, surveys conducted, and a widely accepted in-group Strategy Document was created, called Red Hot and Fair: A Strategy For Equality in The Annual Picnic Season. The Green Chilli Group simply met and socialized. They too were happy.

The Red Hot and Fair documents were sent to the government. It was controversial because it involved a significant change of habits. The Red Chilli Group were praised for their creativity and ability to work without major disagreements, unlike in local town meetings. The gist of the policy document was to have a green chilli picnic in one town, a simultaneous red chilli picnic in the other town, and cheap transport between the towns. Each year the parties would be held in alternate parties, so that every two years each town had one of each type of picnic. This would draw like-minded people together, and they could eat the chilli of their own choice.

After the events were held, the Chilli Pulse Survey showed everyone had been happy, including the Red Chilli group who had initially been regarded as reactionary and unlikely ever to be happy. Nobody felt excluded.

Comments on the Chilli Pepper Problem

Even though this story is a simple one, it can help to show some of the issues regarding diversity and inclusion. The following bullet points are just a few that stand out for me:

  • Where there are differences in a group, voting to obtain a majority decision results in some people regularly getting a consistently unfavorable outcome.
  • Even though groups may be ‘inclusive’, group decisions hide the minority views. Effectively the minority view becomes marginalized.
  • Feedback helps to identify minority views.
  • Attempts to solve the problem of diversity in a mixed group can result in alienation of people with minority views.
  • The freedom to associate with others with shared views results in decisions

that everyone agrees with in the group, and the group being happy.

  • Groups with minority views need the same influence and voting rights as

groups with majority views, if happiness is to be maximized.

Personally, I do not like either red or green chilli peppers, so I am not moving to either town in that country.

References

Roscoe, 2019: Advancing Diversity, Inclusion and social Justice through Human Systems Engineering, https://www.amazon.co.uk/Advancing-Diversity-Inclusion-Justice-Engineering/dp/1138387983
Juday, 2017: Inclusion Isn’t Being asked to Dance, https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/inclusion-isnt-being-asked-dance-daniel-juday
Miles, 2012: Diversity is Being Asked to the Party, https://www.cleveland.com/business/2016/05/diversity_is_being_invited_to.html (Miller, Page 2007): Complex Adaptive Systems, https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691127026/complex-adaptive-systems

Anonymous
Announcements
  • Coming soon: Partner access to confidential technical content

    Chris Royston
    Chris Royston
    If your organization has an entitlement to it, and has decided that you can have access, you will soon be able to search for and view confidential product documentation in the Arm Developer documentation…
    • February 7, 2023
  • Creating the new normal in Arm Technical Training

    Matt_Rushton
    Matt_Rushton
    This blog covers the progress that has been made in adapting to these challenges and the exciting plans we have for the year ahead.
    • January 26, 2023
  • Meet Arm ecosystem partners at the Arm Tech Symposia

    Elsa Wen
    Elsa Wen
    The annual largest Arm technology forum in APAC, Arm Tech Symposia, is back and running from November 2 until December 1. Learn more about it here.
    • November 14, 2022