This discussion has been locked.

You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Cortex M3 - Right Shift Bug

Hi,

I'm using uVision 3.33, supplied as part of the Luminary Micro design contest. I've noticed the following problem when trying to right-shift a 16-bit unsigned value.

The code produced is:-

   176: unsigned short int16;
   177:
   178: void testfunc(void)
   179: {
0x0000072E BD10      POP      {r4,pc}
   180:         int16 >>= 1;
0x00000730 480A      LDR      r0,[pc,#40]  ; @0x0000075C
0x00000732 8800      LDRH     r0,[r0,#0x00]
0x00000734 4909      LDR      r1,[pc,#36]  ; @0x0000075C
0x00000736 8008      STRH     r0,[r1,#0x00]
   181: }

.. which does not do a right shift !

If I do a left shift, however, it works:-

   176: unsigned short int16;
   177:
   178: void testfunc(void)
   179: {
0x0000072E BD10      POP      {r4,pc}
   180:         int16 <<= 1;
0x00000730 480C      LDR      r0,[pc,#48]  ; @0x00000764
0x00000732 8800      LDRH     r0,[r0,#0x00]
0x00000734 F64F71FF  MOVW     r1,#0xFFFF
0x00000738 EA010040  AND      r0,r1,r0,LSL #1
0x0000073C 4909      LDR      r1,[pc,#36]  ; @0x00000764
0x0000073E 8008      STRH     r0,[r1,#0x00]
   181: }

.. with the LSL instruction clearly visible.

Is this a known bug in the Keil compiler ?

Thanks,

Pete Baston.

Parents

0 Pete Baston over 18 years ago in reply to Gp F

Hi Peter

Here's the version info from my uVision.

Best Regards,

Pete.

IDE-Version:
µVision3 V3.33b
Copyright (c) Keil Elektronik GmbH / Keil Software, Inc. 1995 - 2006

License Information:
Peter Baston
PB Engineering
LIC=----

Tool Version Numbers:
Toolchain Path:    C:\Program Files\Keil\ARM\BIN30\ 
C Compiler:         ARMCC.Exe       V3.0.0.942
Assembler:          ARMASM.Exe       V3.0.0.942
Linker/Locator:     ARMLINK.Exe       V3.0.0.942
Librarian:          ARMAR.Exe       V3.0.0.942
Hex Converter:      FROMELF.Exe       V3.0.0.942
CPU DLL:            SARMCM3.DLL       V3.01
Dialog DLL:         DLM.DLL       V1.00a
Target DLL:         BIN\lmidk-agdi.dll       V???
Dialog DLL:         TLM.DLL       V1.00

Reply

0 Pete Baston over 18 years ago in reply to Gp F

Hi Peter

Here's the version info from my uVision.

Best Regards,

Pete.

IDE-Version:
µVision3 V3.33b
Copyright (c) Keil Elektronik GmbH / Keil Software, Inc. 1995 - 2006

License Information:
Peter Baston
PB Engineering
LIC=----

Tool Version Numbers:
Toolchain Path:    C:\Program Files\Keil\ARM\BIN30\ 
C Compiler:         ARMCC.Exe       V3.0.0.942
Assembler:          ARMASM.Exe       V3.0.0.942
Linker/Locator:     ARMLINK.Exe       V3.0.0.942
Librarian:          ARMAR.Exe       V3.0.0.942
Hex Converter:      FROMELF.Exe       V3.0.0.942
CPU DLL:            SARMCM3.DLL       V3.01
Dialog DLL:         DLM.DLL       V1.00a
Target DLL:         BIN\lmidk-agdi.dll       V???
Dialog DLL:         TLM.DLL       V1.00

Children

0 Gp F over 18 years ago in reply to Pete Baston

Pete,

I am running the following version, which is RVCT3.0 with service pack 1:

IDE-Version:
µVision3 V3.50
Copyright (c) Keil Elektronik GmbH / Keil Software, Inc. 1995 - 2007

Tool Version Numbers:
Toolchain Path:    BIN30\ 
C Compiler:         ARM/Thumb C/C++ Compiler, RVCT3.0 [Build 951] for uVision [Full]
Assembler:          ARM/Thumb Macro Assembler, RVCT3.0 [Build 951] for uVision [Full]
Linker/Locator:     ARM Linker, RVCT3.0 [Build 951] for uVision [Full]
Librarian:          ARM Archiver, RVCT3.0 [Build 951] for uVision
Hex Converter:      ARM FromELF, RVCT3.0 [Build 951] for uVision [Full]
CPU DLL:            SARM.DLL       V3.04
Dialog DLL:         DARMAT.DLL       V1.04
Target DLL:         BIN\UL2ARM.DLL       V1.26
Dialog DLL:         TARMAT.DLL       V1.03

Regards,
Peter