Arm Community
Arm Community
  • Site
  • User
  • Site
  • Search
  • User
  • Groups
    • Arm Research
    • DesignStart
    • Education Hub
    • Innovation
    • Open Source Software and Platforms
  • Forums
    • AI and ML forum
    • Architectures and Processors forum
    • Arm Development Platforms forum
    • Arm Development Studio forum
    • Arm Virtual Hardware forum
    • Automotive forum
    • Compilers and Libraries forum
    • Graphics, Gaming, and VR forum
    • High Performance Computing (HPC) forum
    • Infrastructure Solutions forum
    • Internet of Things (IoT) forum
    • Keil forum
    • Morello Forum
    • Operating Systems forum
    • SoC Design and Simulation forum
    • 中文社区论区
  • Blogs
    • AI and ML blog
    • Announcements
    • Architectures and Processors blog
    • Automotive blog
    • Graphics, Gaming, and VR blog
    • High Performance Computing (HPC) blog
    • Infrastructure Solutions blog
    • Innovation blog
    • Internet of Things (IoT) blog
    • Mobile blog
    • Operating Systems blog
    • Research Articles
    • SoC Design and Simulation blog
    • Smart Homes
    • Tools, Software and IDEs blog
    • Works on Arm blog
    • 中文社区博客
  • Support
    • Open a support case
    • Documentation
    • Downloads
    • Training
    • Arm Approved program
    • Arm Design Reviews
  • Community Help
  • More
  • Cancel
Arm Community blogs
Arm Community blogs
Embedded blog The Technical and Business Side of Custom SoCs vs. Discrete IC Boards
  • Blogs
  • Mentions
  • Sub-Groups
  • Tags
  • Jump...
  • Cancel
More blogs in Arm Community blogs
  • AI and ML blog

  • Announcements

  • Architectures and Processors blog

  • Automotive blog

  • Embedded blog

  • Graphics, Gaming, and VR blog

  • High Performance Computing (HPC) blog

  • Infrastructure Solutions blog

  • Internet of Things (IoT) blog

  • Operating Systems blog

  • SoC Design and Simulation blog

  • Tools, Software and IDEs blog

Tags
  • circuit boards
  • Software
  • hardware
  • custom
  • soc;
  • 180nm
  • asic
  • moore's law
  • embedded-development
  • asic_design
  • soc
  • ip
  • board_level_solution
  • cost
Actions
  • RSS
  • More
  • Cancel
Related blog posts
Related forum threads

The Technical and Business Side of Custom SoCs vs. Discrete IC Boards

John Blyler
John Blyler
December 1, 2015

New data shows that the break-even, return on investment (RoI) point continues to fall as custom SoCs compete directly with traditional discrete IC board designs.

By jblyler, Editorial Director, JB Systems

Compelling quotes:

> “Is a single soc; really a viable alternative to board-level implementations? … no matter the process node, there is always a (proportionally) hefty NRE.”

> “Small to medium businesses care much less about the unit cost than in minimizing their NRE cost.

> “The breakpoints occur where the foundries force small and medium customers to transition from a MPW to a dedicated mask (see Figure).”

> “The real tipping point (for affordable custom SoCs) occurred around 2010 to 2011 when three things happened – decreasing price of silicon, emergence of specific application domains, and a fragmented IoT market… in which large companies have no particular advantage.”

> “So how can OEM’s determine this break-even point? First, they must get a reasonable estimate for the cost of a custom SoC … (following the) Rule of 50”

> “Hardware is the new software.”

> “… (a) carpet machine company moved to a customer ASIC instead of the traditional discrete component board. To their satisfaction, that product has been the only machine that wasn’t cloned.”

imec IC-link data_jb_i_crop.jpg

Figure: Custom SoC industrialization pathway curves for 180nm, 90nm and (relatively lower node) 40nm,

show the cost vs. volume and the breakpoints when small and medium companies must shift from MPW

to a dedicated mask for limited runs. (Courtesy imec IC-link)

For years it’s been acknowledged and even trendy to cast hardware as a mere commodity. In general, software has replaced hardware as the differentiator in the embedded space. Hardware has become a commodity in part due to the benefits offered by Moore’s law in power, performance and price.

But in the semiconductor chip world, moore's law is finally slowing. While transistor density continues to increase, the rate is decelerating. In 1990, transistors doubled every 18 months while today that happens every 24 months. As Andrew Huang notes in a recent IEEE article, “transistor density improvements will slow to a pace of 36 months per generation, and eventually they will reach an effective standstill.”

The slowing of Moore’s Law applies to leading edge geometric nodes, now somewhere near 14nm. But what is often forgotten is that trailing edge, mature nodes are still decreasing in price. For example, 180nm wafer costs continue to decrease by about 5% per year.

What happened to make custom asics an affordable implementation strategy for start-ups and small to medium businesses? The answer lies in the falling wafer costs at mature nodes combined with the emergence of application domains that are well suited for these mature technologies and the low volumes in the very fragmented IoT market.

Another converging trend is the staggering economic damage caused by the theft of intellectual property (ip) and the cloning of board_level_designs designs. But here, too, ASICs provide a benefit. It is very difficult to reverse engineer a custom ASIC. That’s one reason why Jio Ito, the director of the media lab at MIT, calls hardware the new software. Today’s hardware startups look like yesterday’s software counterparts. That is why the spin-offs coming out of MIT are actually working in hardware rather than software - because of the falling costs of ASICs and the afforded IP protection.

Finally, custom ASICs are a bulwark against the supply chain obsolescence of board-level components. When a supplier decides to stop supplying a particular component, the customer may have to redesign their product board. The end-of-life (EoL) scenario is a significant trigger for many companies when considering a custom SoC.

Want to learn more? Please read the details in the whitepaper: Custom SoCs Compete with Discrete IC Boards

Anonymous
Embedded blog
  • The cloud-native approach to the software defined car

    Girish Shirasat
    Girish Shirasat
    Cloud native approaches are critical to enabling the software defined car, read more in this blog post.
    • September 14, 2021
  • Arm and ETAS partner to optimize model-based development for Arm devices

    Guilherme Marshall
    Guilherme Marshall
    Arm and ETAS bring optimum runtime performance and simplified development flow for model-based development and automated code generation in safety applications
    • January 7, 2021
  • The Flexible Approach to Adding Functional Safety to a CPU

    Naresh Menon
    Naresh Menon
    Find out more about Functional Safety with SoC designs and Software Test Libraries.
    • October 22, 2020