Hi experts,
I want to knows why there are 4 core cores per cluster in ARM big.Littte architecture?
Is it possiable if we make more cores per cluster? if not, what is the limitation?
Hi,
The ARMv8 architecture does not mandate 4 cores per cluster.
Technically the architecture does not even define the concept of cores and clusters, instead defining the concept of "PE affinity" (where "PE" is short for processing element, i.e. anything with a program counter - this could be a single-threaded core, or each thread in a hardware-multi-threaded core, etc).
The affinity of a PE is split into 3-4 fields that can be used in whichever way you like. The only limitation that the architecture places on the use of these fields is that:
"The assigned value of the MPIDR.{Aff2, Aff1, Aff0} or MPIDR_EL1.{Aff3, Aff2, Aff1, Aff0} setof fields of each PE must be unique within the system as a whole."
- ARMv8-A Architecture Reference Manual (ARM DDI 0487A.j) section D7.2.67 MPIDR_EL1
A typical use case is to treat Aff1 as the cluster ID and Aff0 as the core ID.
You may have noticed that ARM's own implementations such as the ARM Cortex-A53 MPCore can be configured to have between 1 and 4 cores; this is simply a design decision of that particular processor implementation, not a limitation mandated by the architecture. Your own processor implementation can allow as many cores as you design it to have.
Hope that helps.
Currently we see only implementations of up to 4 CPUs (or PEs) per cluster.
So is there a limit in the cache IP for this or is it just a "practical" problem to have e.g. 8 cache-coherent PEs in a cluster?
I suspect it's just a question of "4 is enough" for most use cases. Why complicate the design with more cores than most uses cases actually require?
Peter,
but there are for example the LS1088A, which comes with 8(!) A72 cores. But in two clusters of 4. But we'll never know why, NXP/Freescale did it.
I never saw more then 4 cores in a cluster, so there must be some limiting factor.
View all questions in Cortex-A / A-Profile forum